EPISODE 135

Hybrid Trust Erodes Quietly

Most employees say they're productive. Most leaders aren't sure. In hybrid teams, trust doesn't break loudly. It drains away.

listen on

In this episode

In hybrid teams, employees say they’re productive and their managers aren’t so sure. Neither side says it out loud, and trust drains away without a single argument. Claire and Edwin look at where the trust gap comes from, why watching people harder makes it worse, and what actually rebuilds it.

Transcript

Welcome to the show everybody! Today I want to talk about trust in hybrid teams, because there's a gap in the data that I can't stop thinking about. Microsoft surveyed more than twenty thousand people across eleven countries for its 2022 Work Trend Index. Eighty seven percent of employees said they were productive at work. But eighty five percent of leaders said hybrid work made it hard to be confident their people were productive. Only twelve percent of leaders had full confidence in their teams.


Eighty seven percent on one side, twelve percent on the other. That's not a disagreement about productivity. It's a disagreement about evidence. The employees are judging by the work they finished. The leaders are judging by what they could see. And in a hybrid team, a leader sees a great deal less than they used to.


Microsoft called it productivity paranoia.


A good name, because paranoia is exactly what fills the space where information used to be. In an office, a manager absorbed a thousand small signals without trying. Who stayed late, who helped whom, who seemed stuck. Remove those signals and the mind doesn't stay neutral. It assumes the worst.


And Gallup's data suggests the managers feel it. Only fifty four percent of managers who supervise remote employees strongly agree that they trust their teams to be productive when working remotely. And only fifty seven percent of remote employees strongly agree that they feel trusted by their manager.


And notice how quiet that is. No one has had an argument. No one has been accused of anything. But nearly half of those managers don't fully trust their people, and nearly half of those people can feel it. That's the danger of hybrid trust. It doesn't break loudly. It erodes, one unanswered message at a time.


So what do managers usually do when they don't trust what they can't see?


They try to see more. More status meetings. More check ins that are really check ups. Monitoring software. Expectations that everyone is visibly online. And every one of those moves sends the same message to the team: I don't believe you. Which is the fastest way to turn a trust gap into a real productivity problem, because people who feel watched stop taking initiative. They optimize for looking busy.


And there's a fairness problem, too. If recognition follows whoever's most visible, the people in the office get credit and the people at home get overlooked.


That's right. Visibility becomes a proxy for performance, and it's a poor one. Some of your strongest people do their best work where nobody can see them do it.


Let's get to what actually works, because Gallup has some encouraging numbers on this. In a 2024 study of hybrid workers, they found that nearly half said their team had never discussed a plan for how to collaborate in a hybrid setup. But the teams that did have a plan were sixty six percent more likely to be engaged and twenty nine percent less likely to be burned out.


That's a remarkable return on a single conversation. And it makes sense. Most hybrid friction isn't about character. It's about unspoken assumptions. When do we need to be reachable? How fast should a message get answered? Which decisions happen in a meeting, and which in writing? When nobody has agreed on those things, every delay looks like neglect.


Gallup also found that when teams set their hybrid schedule together, ninety one percent called the policy fair, compared with seventy three percent when leadership decided it alone.


People trust a rule they helped make. That's as old as leadership itself.


So if you're a manager listening who feels that trust gap right now, what do you do on Monday?


Four things. First, judge by outcomes, not presence. Agree on what good results look like for each person and measure that, the same way for everyone, wherever they sit. Second, hold a real one on one with each person every week. Not a status update. A conversation about progress, obstacles, workload and how they're doing. Third, explain your decisions, especially to the people who weren't in the room when you made them. And fourth, write things down. When the people in the office and the people at home have the same information, you've removed the biggest single source of hybrid resentment.


And one more step, from the Gallup data: build those team agreements together.


Exactly. Don't hand the team a policy. Sit down with them and agree on how you'll work.


I'd guess some managers find all of this harder than others.


Much harder, and it's worth knowing in advance. Some leaders are wired to need structure and visibility to feel in control, and hybrid work takes exactly that away from them. Others are comfortable leading by outcomes from day one. Neither is a character flaw. But it tells you which managers will need support before they start reaching for monitoring tools. A validated behavioral assessment can show which way a manager leans before the pressure arrives. It’s one structured input, but it helps you match the support to the manager instead of guessing.


If you want to see what your best people have in common before the next trust question comes up, start with the person you trust most. OAD's free Top Performer Profile takes seven minutes, results come back in twenty four hours, and there's no credit card. That's O-A-D dot A-I.


You can't watch your way to trust. You have to agree your way there.


Perfect place to leave it. Thanks for the wisdom.


Always a pleasure.

From the mic to your team

Liked what you heard? Try it on your own team.

OAD gives you the same clarity on people our guests talk about, from a 7-minute behavioral survey and instant insights.