Hey, welcome back to The Science of Leading. I'm Claire Monroe—and yep, Edwin Carrington is here too. The calm to my chaos. So today we're digging into something that totally tripped me up early on in my career: the difference between high performers… and high potentials. It sounds obvious—until you actually try to spot the difference. Edwin, this one feels simple… but then it really isn't?
Right—and that's the trap. Most managers—honestly, most companies—tend to blur the two. High performers? They crush it in their current role. They deliver results. You know, the reliable stars. But high potential is about what someone could do. It's future-facing. So we're talking about adaptability, hunger to learn, willingness to take on ambiguous challenges—plus the capacity to grow beyond what they're doing now. It's not just about what's visible today. It's what's underneath.
Oh, totally. I remember that moment clearly. I'd just wrapped a project that got a ton of praise—was feeling pretty great. But then someone else, a peer, got tapped for this "future leader" track… and I was like—wait, aren't we both killing it here? That was the first time I realized… performance and potential aren't the same currency.
And you're not alone. It's a common blind spot. High performers keep things running—but high potentials? They push toward what's next. You'll often spot them asking about things outside their lane. Volunteering for messy, undefined work. They're curious, strategic, connected to the big picture. And here's the nuance: it's not just ambition. It's a kind of applied curiosity. They don't just want to climb—they want to understand. To shape what's coming.
Okay, but… some high performers don't want to change lanes. They're like, laser-focused. Happy where they are. So is it fair to say we need to support those folks differently?
Exactly. That's the key. You don't try to turn everyone into a future VP. High performers deserve investment to deepen their excellence—give them recognition, resources, autonomy. High potentials? You stretch them. Leadership development, mentorship, visibility across functions. But it starts by knowing who's who.
So if you're managing a team—watch for the people who deliver and lean into discomfort. The ones who ask the hard questions. Easier said than done… but yeah, this makes it clearer. Thanks, Edwin.
Let's shift gears. Let's talk programs. Because… oof, I've seen some HiPo programs that felt more like... I don't know, awkward talent shows? Why do so many of these fall flat?
Intent is good—but execution's often stuck in the past. Traditional HiPo programs pick a small, senior group—like they're choosing the varsity team. But data tells us that's short-sighted. DDI's global leadership forecast found that organizations who cast a wider net—down to first-level managers, even early-career staff—see stronger pipelines and better business outcomes. Widen the lens, and you uncover hidden talent. Talent that would've been missed.
It sounds like common sense—but so many companies still default to, "Let's pick our top performers and call it a day." And how they pick them… isn't it usually just gut instinct?
Unfortunately, yes. And that's where bias creeps in. The strongest programs use structured, objective tools. Behavioral assessments. Psychometric data. They don't just look for who's already shiny—they look for signals of potential. And here's the kicker: development needs to be immersive. Not just a one-time training. Think simulations, stretch assignments, real-world exposure. And ongoing coaching—not a check-the-box workshop. A relationship.
You shared a story once about a mid-sized tech company that really flipped the HiPo playbook… I thought it was interesting because they weren't huge. Can you give our listeners a sense of what they actually changed?
Glad you brought that up. They realized they were missing great future leaders because all their HiPo picks looked the same—already rising stars. So they broadened eligibility, used objective assessments for selection, and, critically, invested in a coaching model across departments. Instead of just a training series, every potential got a dedicated coach, and they rotated through different business units on stretch assignments. The effect was dramatic: not only did their internal leadership pipeline get deeper, but engagement improved, and, frankly, their financial performance followed. It's a clear case for going deeper and wider, not just higher.
It's like—if you're building a strong bench, you can't just train your starting five. You've gotta coach the whole team. Otherwise when someone gets promoted—or leaves—you've got no one ready.
Exactly. Development isn't a luxury for the elite. It's how you build resilience.
Okay—so let's say you do the work. You identify high potentials. You develop them. How do you keep them? Because if they leave, after all that effort—man, you're back to square one.
Retention is where the rubber meets the road. High potentials want clarity: a transparent path forward. They want challenge—real responsibility, not busywork. And they want regular feedback that matters. Recognition, too—formally identifying someone as high potential boosts retention significantly. One study showed it cuts the risk of them looking elsewhere by more than half.
That tracks. One of my friends—she got formally named a HiPo last year. Her company made it public, gave her a mentor, and threw her some big stretch goals. She told me it completely changed her mindset. Like—"I can see a future here now." But the cool part? She started mentoring junior folks, too. She's got a lot on her plate, but she's paying it forward.
And that's the ripple effect you want. High potentials who develop others don't just grow your pipeline—they build your culture. It's how you multiply your investment. It's how leadership becomes contagious.
So it's not about just dangling a title. It's about trust. Visibility. Purposeful feedback. And when people feel seen—they stick around. And they bring others up with them.
That's the whole game. The organizations that thrive aren't the ones chasing quick wins. They're the ones building systems that sustain themselves. Investing in people—especially your potential—that's not fluff. That's the strategy.
Whew. That's a wrap, huh? Such a good one today. And if you're listening and wondering how to actually do all this—like, in your org— You can test out OAD's tools for free at o-a-d-dot-a-i. Their behavioral assessments make it way easier to spot potential early and build the right support.
Couldn't agree more. Thanks for tuning in, everyone.
See you next time on The Science of Leading.