EPISODE 132

Speak in Their Currency

Your idea didn't fail because it was wrong. It failed because you pitched it in a currency your executives don't spend.

listen on

In this episode

Good ideas die in executive meetings every day, and usually not because they’re wrong. Claire and Edwin break down how to get a senior leader to say yes without a big title or budget: framing in the currency executives actually spend, structuring the ask, reading how each leader decides, and treating pushback as a sign you’re being heard.

Transcript

Welcome to the show everybody! Today's topic is one I think almost every listener has lived through. You have a good idea. You know it's a good idea. You take it to the leadership team, and it dies. Nobody says no, exactly. It just never comes back. Susan Ashford and James Detert studied this for Harvard Business Review. They called it issue selling, the way people get leaders to pay attention to an idea. And the first two tactics on their list were to tailor the pitch to the decision maker's priorities, and to link the idea directly to the organization's strategy.


Which tells you where most pitches go wrong. People assume an idea fails because they lack authority. A bigger title, a bigger budget. In my experience, ideas rarely die from lack of authority. They die from being pitched in the wrong currency. Executives spend in four currencies: revenue, cost, risk and strategy. If your idea is priced in anything else, it doesn't matter how good it is. They can't spend it.


Let me give you a scenario. Picture a people operations manager at a company of about a hundred fifty people. She's pitched a redesign of onboarding three times. Every time, it stalls. Every time, she presents it as an HR project, with a lot about engagement and the new hire experience.


And on the fourth attempt?


On the fourth attempt she changes one thing. Her opening sentence. Something like: we're losing more than one in five new hires before month six, and it's costing us hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to replace them. Same project. Same person. Same title. Approved that quarter.


That's the whole lesson in one story. Her authority didn't change. Her translation did. She stopped describing what HR wanted and started describing what the business was losing. The first version asked leaders to care about her world. The second version showed up in theirs.


So once you've got the right currency, how should the pitch actually be built?


Executives scan for signal, so give them a structure they can scan. Five parts. The problem: what's happening and why it matters now. The impact: what it costs, in their currency. The options: two or three real paths, with the tradeoffs of each. Your recommendation: which one you'd choose and why. And the ask: the specific decision, money or people you need. In a formal meeting, that should fit on one page. In a one on one, start with the recommendation.


That's very close to what Barbara Minto taught consultants at McKinsey decades ago with her Pyramid Principle. Lead with the answer, then support it. Don't make a senior leader sit through your whole thought process to find out what you want.


Exactly. And notice what's in that structure that most pitches skip. Options. When you bring only one idea, the executive's only choices are yes or no, and no is safer. When you bring options with tradeoffs, you've done the thinking they'd otherwise have to do, and you've given them something to decide between rather than something to reject.


Let's talk about data, because everyone tells you to bring data. KPMG's 2026 Adaptability Index found that sixty three percent of executives say they're relying more on data and analytics. But fewer than half, forty three percent, say their decisions are actually getting faster or clearer.


That gap is the opportunity. Executives aren't short of data. They're drowning in it. So more numbers won't make your pitch stand out. The data that persuades is data that corrects something they currently believe. If your numbers confirm what everyone already thinks, they're decoration. If they overturn an assumption, they're news.


So the most powerful slide is the one that says, here's what we thought was true, and here's what the data actually shows.


Precisely. And then you tie it straight back to the currency. Not, here's an interesting finding. Instead, here's an interesting finding, and here's what it's costing us.


Here's the part I find hardest, though. Not every executive decides the same way. Some want the numbers. Some want the big picture. Some want to be part of building the idea.


And most people pitch every executive the same way, usually the way they themselves like to be pitched. That's a mistake. A leader who decides fast wants your recommendation in the first sentence. A leader who needs structure wants your sources and your assumptions laid out before they'll commit. A consensus builder wants to shape the idea with you before it's presented. A risk averse leader needs to see the cost of doing nothing. Same idea, four different doors.


The problem is that most of us are guessing at which door. We've been in two meetings with that executive and we're reading their style from body language.


That's where it pays to ask. Talk to people who work with that executive, look at how they've decided in the past, and notice what they ask for first, instead of guessing from one meeting. But it's one structured input. It's not a substitute for paying attention to the person in front of you.


Last piece. What happens when the executive pushes back? Because that's usually where people fold.


Pushback is the best thing that can happen in that meeting. An executive who pushes back is engaging with your idea. Silence is far more dangerous. So don't defend, explore. Pause. Ask which risk worries them most. Restate the concern so they know you heard it. Then reframe it in their terms. A cost objection, for example, can often be answered as a risk argument. What does it cost if we don't do this?


And Ashford and Detert had a tactic for the meeting before the meeting, too. Bring other people in.


Yes. Never let the formal meeting be the first time a key leader hears your idea. Meet the allies one on one beforehand, and tailor the value to each of them. The finance leader hears about cost. The people leader hears about the leadership pipeline. By the time you walk into the room, the decision has already started.


If you want to understand how the people around you actually make decisions, start with the person you trust most on your team. OAD's free Top Performer Profile takes seven minutes, results come back in twenty four hours, and there's no credit card. That's O-A-D dot A-I.


Influence was never about the size of your title. It's about how well you translate.


Perfect place to leave it. Thanks for the wisdom.


Always a pleasure.

From the mic to your team

Liked what you heard? Try it on your own team.

OAD gives you the same clarity on people our guests talk about, from a 7-minute behavioral survey and instant insights.